High-load operation severely challenges boiler heating surfaces, primarily causing wall temperature exceedance, abnormal thermal stress escalation, and accelerated corrosion. The core strategy to prevent leaks in water walls and other heating surfaces is “proactive prevention and comprehensive management”, integrating operational optimization, technical monitoring, maintenance protocols, and equipment upgrades. Critical emphasis must be placed on: maintaining oxidizing atmospheres during operation to suppress corrosion, precise temperature control to delay material aging, and precision management to minimize thermal fatigue from abrupt temperature changes. During every outage, thorough professional anti-erosion & anti-explosion inspections must be conducted to proactively eliminate hidden risks, thus ensuring efficient, safe, and stable boiler operation under high loads.
Core Causes of Water Wall Tube Leakage in Utility Boilers Under High Load
1. Significant Increase in Metal Wall Temperature:
- Sharp rise in heat flux: Intensive combustion at high load elevates flame core/average furnace temperatures, drastically increasing radiant heat transfer.
- Enhanced in-furnace heat exchange: Higher heat absorption for steam generation exposes water wall tubes to elevated flue gas temperatures.
- Working fluid behavior: Increased inlet water flow/velocity may occur, but localized areas (e.g., near burners or high heat flux zones) can experience flow stagnation, steam-water stratification, or DNB, causing inadequate internal cooling and metal temperature spikes.
- Material temperature limits approached: Advanced materials (T12/T23/T91/T92) operate near allowable temperature limits. Excessive wall temperatures accelerate creep, reduce allowable stress, and increase stress-induced deformation/cracking risks.
2. Increased & Non-Uniform Thermal Stresses:
- Steepened temperature gradients: Large differentials between zones (inter-tube, inter-panel, fire-facing/back sides) generate severe axial/radial thermal stresses.
- Differential expansion: Non-uniform heating creates constraint stresses at buckstays, hangers, and seals due to mismatched expansion.
- Cyclic temperature fluctuations: Load swings, sootblower operations, and coal quality variations induce thermal fatigue stress.
3. Accelerated Corrosion/Oxidation:
- High-temperature flue gas corrosion: Elevated wall temperatures intensify sulfidation, chloridation, and oxidation (especially with high-S/Cl coals).
- Reducing atmosphere corrosion: Improper air distribution (e.g., imbalanced primary air/fuel ratio, insufficient secondary air penetration) creates localized reducing atmospheres (CO/H₂S) near burners, destroying protective oxide layers and accelerating water wall wastage.
- Dissolved oxygen: Inadequate deaeration control elevates oxygen levels, causing oxygen corrosion.
4. Increased Erosion Risk (Specific Areas):
- Higher flue gas flow/velocity at high load intensifies ash particle erosion in high-dust zones (e.g., furnace exit platen superheaters, horizontal pass convective surfaces).
5. Manufacturing/Installation Defects Amplified by High Stress:
- Latent flaws—weld microcracks, inclusions, thinned bends—or stress concentration points from installation become leakage initiators under high-load/high-stress conditions.
Case Study 1: High-Temperature Corrosion Leakage in Water Wall Under High-Load Operation
Plant Background: 600MW supercritical coal-fired unit.
Observations:
- Severe external wall thinning detected near burner zones during planned outage after prolonged high-load operation (minimum residual thickness: 2mm vs. design: 7mm).
- Pitting cavities observed on multiple tubes with leakage in some sections.
Root Cause Analysis:
- High-load accelerated corrosion:
- Concentrated heat flux elevated tube wall temperatures beyond corrosion acceleration threshold (>300°C).
- Reducing atmosphere:
- Suboptimal primary/secondary air ratio created oxygen-deficient zones near burners.
- CO >10,000ppm enabled direct metal attack by H₂S from high-sulfur coal.
- Coal quality variations:
- Intermittent burning of coal with sulfur content >1.8%.
Corrective Actions:
- Combustion optimization:
- Adjusted air ratios with SOFA (Separated Over-Fire Air) optimization.
- Maintained CO <200ppm in burner zones.
- Coal management:
- Implemented coal blending to limit sulfur ≤0.8% and ash ≤20%.
- Corrosion protection:
- Applied thermal-sprayed nickel-based alloy coating (Inconel 625) on fire-facing surfaces.
- Enhanced monitoring:
- Installed wall temperature monitors in high-risk zones.
- Deployed continuous flue gas analyzers (CO/O₂).
Case Study 2: Thermal Fatigue-Induced Leakage at Header Stub Fillet Weld
Plant Background: 350MW subcritical unit.
Observations:
- Sudden leakage at fillet weld of lower water wall header stub after consecutive high-load days.
Root Cause Analysis:
- Temperature fluctuations:
- Frequent sootblower operations and load swings caused temperature transients >5°C/min.
- Structural stress concentration:
- Geometric discontinuity at weld created stress concentration (Kt=3.2).
- Thermal fatigue:
- Cyclic thermal stresses (ΔT>100°C) initiated fatigue cracks propagating to 85% wall thickness.
Corrective Actions:
- Operational optimization:
- Implemented zonal sootblowing with pressure control (≤1.8MPa).
- Limited load ramping to ≤4MW/min (temperature transients ≤2°C/min).
- Structural enhancement:
- Performed profile grinding on new welds (transition radius R≥8mm, Kt<1.5).
- Enhanced NDE protocol:
- Designated as priority inspection zone during outages.
- Conducted phased array UT (PAUT) examinations biennially.
Mitigating Leakage Risks Under High Load: Core Elements of a Systematic Defense System
I. Operational Optimization – Preventing Overheating & Eliminating Corrosion Environments
Precision Combustion Tuning:
- Maintain furnace exit O₂ at 2.5-3.5% via combustion tests, optimizing damper openings and air/fuel ratios to ensure oxidizing atmosphere (Critical!).
- Eliminate localized reducing zones through continuous CO monitoring (target: <200 ppm).
- Control primary air velocity (18-25 m/s) and temperature (70-85°C), optimize swirl intensity/direct-flow rigidity to stabilize flame standoff.
- Ensure coal uniformity via mill optimization and pulverized coal fineness control (R90 ≤ 20%).
Strict Wall Temperature Control:
- Validate DCS temperature sensors; enforce material-specific wall temperature limits (e.g., T91 ≤ 600°C).
- Optimize sootblowing: frequency, sequence, and steam pressure (≤2.0 MPa) to balance ash removal with thermal shock prevention.
- Implement precise coal blending to avoid abrupt fuel property changes (e.g., ash fusion temperature ±50°C, S ≤ 0.8%, Cl ≤ 0.2%).
Working Fluid Quality Assurance:
- Ensure reliable deaeration (dissolved O₂ ≤ 5 ppb).
- Maintain feedwater/steam pH (9.0-9.6) and boiler water chemistry via controlled dosing.
- Prevent salt deposition to avoid scaling-induced heat transfer deterioration.
II. Maintenance & Inspection – Early Detection & Proactive Intervention
Systematic Examinations:
| Method | Application |
|---|---|
| Ultrasonic thickness gauging | Corrosion-thinned zones (e.g., burner belt fire-facing surfaces) |
| MT/PT | Surface cracks in welds, bends, and fittings |
| UT/PAUT/RT | Internal weld defects and wall damage |
| Endoscopy | Internal scaling, exfoliation, and erosion |
| Metallographic analysis | Material aging assessment (e.g., spheroidization rating) at suspected hotspots |
Shutdown Protocol:
- Full visual inspection of furnace water walls (burner zones, arch, penetrations, sootblower-affected areas) during all outages.
NDT Technology Deployment:
- State Monitoring & Life Assessment:
- Build databases for wall/fluid/flue gas temperatures and composition.
- Predict remaining life using operational data, material conditions, and inspection results (e.g., creep life assessment per EN 12952-11).
- Tag and track high-risk tube sections.
- Proactive Replacement & Repair:
- Replace tubes nearing end-of-life or with severe thinning (>30%), creep damage, or deep cracks.
- Upgrade to advanced materials (e.g., T92 for headers, HR3C for platens).
- Apply protective coatings (e.g., HVOF-sprayed NiCr) in corrosion-prone areas.
- Modify high-fatigue welds with radius grinding (R ≥ 5mm) to extend service life.
III. Equipment Management – Enhanced Design, Materials & Monitoring
Design Optimization (Retrofits/Upgrades):
- Optimize furnace dimensions, burner arrangement, and heating surface layout (e.g., wider panel spacing) to minimize thermal deviation.
- Eliminate flue gas bypass flow paths (“烟气走廊”).
- Specify superior materials (e.g., Super 304H) for high-stress zones.
- Design comprehensive temperature and flue gas monitoring points.
Sensor Enhancement:
- Add wall thermocouples at critical locations:
- Burner zones & high-overheating-risk areas (spacing ≤ 3m).
- Platen superheater regions (external/internal measurements).
- Strengthen flue gas monitoring:
- Install multi-level CO/O₂ analyzers in furnace (upper/lower combustion zones).
- Ensure data accuracy:
- Calibrate all instruments quarterly per IEC 61511.
